Vicars general
- 1834-1839 — Very Rev. Simon P. Lalumière
- 1836-1839 — Very Rev. Célestin de la Hailandière
- 1842-1846 — Very Rev. Auguste M. Martin
- 1846-1848 — Very Rev. Hippolyte Du Pontavice
- 1846-1848 — Very Rev. Maurice de Saint-Palais
- 1847-1848 — Very Rev. Edward F. Sorin, CSC
- 1849-1874 — Very Rev. Hippolyte Du Pontavice
- 1849-1851 — Very Rev. Conrad Schniederjans
- 1851-1857 — Very Rev. Joseph Kundek
- 1851-1872 — Very Rev. John B. Corbe
- 1853-1861 — Very Rev. P. Leonard Brandt
- 1869-1875 — Very Rev. Bede O’Connor, OSB
- 1872-1877 — Very Rev. Msgr. August F. Bessonies
- 1876-1877 — Very Rev. John Guéguen
- 1878-1901 — Rt. Rev. Msgr. August F. Bessonies
- 1878-1918 — Very Rev. Anthony R. Scheideler
- 1899-1900 — Very Rev. Denis O’Donaghue
- 1900-1910 — Rt. Rev. Denis O’Donaghue, Auxiliary Bishop
- 1910-1918 — Rt. Rev. Joseph Chartrand, Coadjutor Bishop
- 1918-1932 — Rt. Rev. Msgr. Francis H. Gavisk
- 1933-1933 — Most Rev. Joseph E. Ritter, Auxiliary Bishop
- 1934-1946 — Rt. Rev. Msgr. Raymond R. Noll
- 1946-1959 — Rt. Rev. Msgr. Raymond R. Noll
- 1957-1966 — Rt. Rev. Msgr. Bernard P. Sheridan
- 1966-1979 — Rt. Rev. Msgr. Cornelius B. Sweeney
- 1967-1970 — Most Rev. George J. Biskup, Coadjutor Archbishop
- 1975-1979 — Very Rev. Francis R. Tuohy
- 1980-1988 — Rev. Msgr. Francis R. Tuohy
- 1988-1989 — Rev. Msgr. Gerald A. Gettelfinger
- 1989-1992 — Rev. David E. Coats
- 1992-1994 — Rev. David E. Coats
- 1994-1997 — Very Rev. Joseph F. Schaedel
- 1997-2011 — Rev. Msgr. Joseph F. Schaedel
- 2011 — Most Rev. Christopher J. Coyne, Auxiliary Bishop