Catholics throughout the archdiocese share reactions, thoughts on new pope

Compiled by Natalie Hoefer

“I was shocked that an American was elected, shocked that it was so quickly done, and thrilled with the results. I think reading Pope Leo’s bio, he seems to be in the same vein as Pope Francis, the same inclusive, thoughtful way of doing things, which to me was a really good way to attract people to the Church.”
—Harriet Neill, St. Michael Parish, Cannelton
 

“It was really exciting to watch. When they said he was an American pope—I’m not the town crier, but I got tears in my eyes. The few things I’ve read about him are that he has similar thoughts to Pope Francis, and he may have some good ideas of his own, too. He seems to be a very warm, humble person, and I like the fact that he’s only 69 years old.”
—Linda Ricke, St. Mary Parish, Greensburg
 

“[My wife and I] were both really surprised because we were talking about the chances of it being a U.S. cardinal were pretty low. I think [Pope Leo XIV] is kind of [universal], actually. He’s been in Peru and everywhere. But he is a Midwestern guy, and we’re really proud of that.”
—Craig Moorman, St. Rose of Lima Parish, Franklin
 

“Tom Allen, the previous IU football coach, his acronym for his team was LEO. And it means ‘Love Each Other.’ So, when I saw [the new pope] chose Leo, I thought that was a perfect name.”
—Diana Moorman, St. Rose of Lima Parish, Franklin
 

“I was delighted, and a bit surprised, with what seemed like quick results of the election. It seemed like the Holy Spirit was working overtime. I like very much what I have read of Pope Leo XIV’s background—not only his Peru, North American and U.S. connections but his Chicago roots! His comments seem to align with Pope Francis’ world view and being a shepherd to the world. I’m looking forward to his Papacy.”
—Rosalie Hawthorne, Nativity of Our Lord Jesus Christ Parish, Indianapolis
 

“When I first heard that an American had been selected as our new pope, I was honestly shocked, but also very excited! As a nation, I think it places a lot of responsibility on our shoulders but also presents amazing opportunities to present the faith. I’m very encouraged by what I have heard from Pope Leo XIV thus far and look forward to learning more. God bless his endeavors!”
—Jessica Murphy, St. Joseph University Parish, Terre Haute, and development manager for Terre Haute Catholic Charities
 

“I was so surprised when I heard that the cardinals had chosen an American for our new pope. It is an exciting time for our Church. I think he will bring a new perspective to the papacy. I’m thrilled to have Pope Leo XIV lead our Church!”
—Laura Roggenkamp, St. Mary of the Knobs, Floyd County
 

“My initial reaction was surprise that he was an American. I see him as a man who gives us hope, and I love the fact he chose the name Leo. Pope Leo XIII was the pope of the common working man, like our dads. Working men who went to work every day and responsibly raised their families with the help of their wives and sent their children to Catholic schools. Pope Leo XIII was devoted to Mary, and I consider him a pope of the rosary. So, I hope Pope Leo XIV will bring a renewed devotion to the rosary.”
—Thomas Stader, St. Susanna Parish, Plainfield
 

“I am so excited for Pope Leo XIV’s papacy! Pope Leo XIV gives me so much hope for the young people of the Church. Young people can relate to Pope Leo because of things like his being a baseball fan and loving to play Wordle. Because of this relatability, young people can be more attentive to his teachings. Pope Leo XIV already seems to be such a bright light in the world, and I cannot wait to see all that he does to help build the Kingdom of God!”
—Lily Bauman, SS. Francis and Clare of Assisi Parish, Greenwood, and a senior at Roncalli High School, Indianapolis
 

“When I heard that a new pope had been announced I was hopeful—hopeful that God had his hand in who would fill this important role, not just for the Church but for the whole world. And as I’ve listened to Pope Leo XIV, I’m very hopeful that he will lead us forward in love and resemblance of Jesus Christ.”
—Larissa Cullens, St. Gabriel Parish, Connersville

Related: Local Catholics share unique viewpoints on our new Holy Father | See more news about our new pope