Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
I Was a Stranger and You Welcomed Me (Mt. 25)
2
The Purpose for this Presentation
    • To Listen to what the Bishops Teach
    • about Immigration
    • and to Listen to One Another.


    • The presentation will last approximately an hour,
    • with time for Q and A.
3
History of Immigration
  • Immigration Laws as we know them did not exist until the 1920s
  • Then Quota Laws Slash the Number of New Immigrants
  • Anti-Catholicism and anti-immigration sentiments have always been linked
4
Root Causes of Immigration
  • Push factors drive people from home countries
  • Pull factors draw people north to seek a better life
5
Economic Impact of Immigration
  • Productivity and Growth
  • Taxes and Public Benefits
  • Impact on Native Born Workers
6
Legal Immigration Process
  • Family-based
  • Employment-Based
  • Asylum and Refugee Status
  • Diversity Lottery
  • Application and Cost
7
Politics of Immigration


within the Last 25 Years
8
“Restrictions on Immigration Must be Eased.”
9
Immigration and
Family Values
  • Restrictions on immigration from
  • Mexico must be eased, a fact
  • Bush recognized in an Aug. 29
  • speech.
  • "If you can make a living in America, and you can't find a job in Mexico, family values don't stop at the southern border," he said.
  • "People are coming to work to provide food for their families.”
10
Things Change
11
WHAT REALLY CHANGED?
  • Economics?  Job Creation?
  • Human Rights?  Needs?
  • International Relations with Mexico?
  • National Security?  Politics?
  • Perceptions?  Attitudes?  Fears?
12
What is said about undocumented immigrants or illegal aliens?
  • No one wants illegal immigration
  • Sovereign states have a right to protect their borders
  • Rights of individuals vs. rights of states
  • Rights of individuals and families to migrate within country and across borders
13
How Do

You

See Immigration Now?
14
Mexico comes to Indiana
  • 1990
    • The US census counted 8,500 Hispanics in Indianapolis
    • 1 Sunday Mass in Spanish in the Archdiocese
    • 1 Spanish-speaking priest worked with the community


  • 2007
    • 100,000 Hispanics in Indianapolis
    • 24 Sunday Masses in Spanish
    • 17 Spanish-speaking Priests work part or full time with Hispanics in the Archdiocese in 20 parishes
15
 
16
 
17
What Does The Bible Say?
  • Old Testament
    • Exodus 23:9
    • Leviticus 19:33-34


  • New Testament
    • Matthew 2:13-15
    • Mathew 25:31-46
18
What Do The Popes Say?
    • Holy Family…fleeing into Egypt, is
    • Archtype of every refugee family.
    • - Exsul Familia, Pius XII, August 1952.


    • The Church in America must be a
    • vigilant advocate…of the rights of
    • migrants and their families… even in
    • cases of non-legal immigrantion.
    • -  Eccelsia in America, John Paul II, Jan 1999
19
 
20
What Do the US Bishops Teach?
  • 2000 - Welcoming the Stranger Among Us, 
    Unity in Diversity.


  • 2003 - Strangers No Longer,
    Together on the journey of hope.


  • 2006 - I Was a Stranger, and You Welcomed Me, Meeting Christ in New Neighbors.
21
2000
Welcoming the Stranger…
  • Vision of Unity/Communion/Solidarity
  • We are an immigrant church in a nation of immigrants
  • Cultural Fears
  • Right of nations to control borders
  • Right to dignified human life
22
2003
Strangers No Longer
  • U.S. And Mexican Bishops’ Conferences
  • Global context
  • Migration is beneficial and necessary
  • 5 principles for the discussion
  • National Campaign: Justice for Immigrants
23
2006
I Was a Stranger
  • 5 Indiana Bishops
  • Urgent Indiana issues
  • Urgent National issues
  • Rejection of all anti-immigrant, nativist, ethnocentrist or racist policies
  • Welcome all as Christ himself
24
 Summary of
The U.S. Bishops’ Teaching
  • Persons have the right to find opportunities in their homeland.
  • Persons have the right to migrate to support themselves and their families.
  • Sovereign nations have the right to control their borders.
  • Refugees and asylum seekers should be afforded protection.
  • The human dignity and human rights of undocumented immigrants should be respected.
25
The U.S. Bishops Offer a Solution
  • COMPREHENSIVE REFORM
  • Earned legalization for undocumented
  • Temporary worker program w/ protections
  • Family reunification: End excessive visa delays
  • Due process in law for asylum seekers
26
Shelbyville First Communion
27
Legislators Fail
To Fix A Broken System
    • US Senate
    • - June 2007, Loss of Nerve…
    • - When will something be done….


    • Local and State Reactions
    • - “Enforcement Only” Policies
28
Debate to Diatribe
  • “Illegal Aliens are Illegal”
  • Radio Talk Show Hosts, Lou Dobbs, O’Reilly, etc.
  • IFIRE, FAIR, NUMBERSUSA
  • State and Local Enforcement only Initiatives
  • Federal SAVE Act


29
Columbus Dancers
30
US Bishops Call For A New Debate
  • Current fears
  • Fragmentation and localization
  • Recent Statements
    • Labor Day statement
    • Bishops’ Committee on Immigration
    • Cardinal Mahoney
    • Notre Dame forum
31
What are Our Hopes and Fears?
  • The situation continues
  • Fears and Myths
    • Cultural fears, economic and legal concerns
  • Proposed solutions
    • Deportation
    • Attrition
    • Comprehensive reform

32
Immigration Myths
  • Immigrants don’t pay taxes
  • Immigrants come here to take welfare
  • Immigrants send all their money back to their home countries
  • Immigrants take jobs and opportunity away from Americans
  • Immigrants are a drain on the U.S. economy
  • Immigrants don’t want to learn English or become Americans
  • Today’s immigrants are different than those of 100 years ago
  • Most immigrants cross the border illegally
  • Weak U.S. border enforcement has led to high undocumented immigration
  • The war on terrorism can be won through immigration restrictions
33
Columbus Family
34
The Human Face of Immigration
“Dying to Live”
35
The Next Move is Ours
  • Ask your U.S. Senators and U.S. Reps to support Comprehensive immigration  reform.
  • Ask your IN Senators and Reps to not support enforcement only proposals.
  • Look for more information on the Justice for Immigrants website, www.justiceforimmigrants.org.
  • Or do nothing…
36
Q and A